Federal Constitutional Court
The Federal Constitutional Court (German: Bundesverfassungsgericht; abbreviated: BVerfG) is the highest constitutional court for the Federal Republic of Germany. It was set up by the country's constitution, called the Basic Law (Grundgesetz). For a different German supreme court from 1879 to 1945, see Reichsgericht.
Since the country's republic began after World War II, the court has been based in the city of Karlsruhe. The Federal Court of Justice is also located there.
The court's main job is judicial review. This means it can decide that a law is unconstitutional, so the law is no longer valid. Many other supreme courts can do this too, but the Federal Constitutional Court has more powers. Many people think it is one of the most powerful and active national courts in the world. Unlike some other supreme courts, it is not a regular step in the court process. It does not hear appeals from lower courts or from the Federal Supreme Courts about federal laws.
The court focuses on questions about the constitution and on whether all parts of the government follow it. Changes to the constitution, and new laws passed by parliament, must also be checked by the court. They must match the most basic principles of the Grundgesetz, which are protected by the eternity clause.
Scope
The Basic Law of Germany says that the parliament, the government, and the courts must all follow the constitution. This means the court can decide that the actions of any of these branches are not allowed under the constitution. This can happen if they broke the rules about who can do what and how, or if they did not respect people's civil rights in the Basic Law. The court's powers are set out in article 94 of the Basic Law. Cases can reach it in several set ways. For example, any person may file a constitutional complaint if their fundamental rights were violated and they have already used all other legal options. The federal government, state governments, or a quarter of the Bundestag members can also bring a law to the court through judicial review if they think it goes against the constitution.
Other cases can cover arguments between federal institutions, arguments between the federal and state governments, and challenges to federal election results. The court can also decide whether a political party threatens the free democratic basic order. It has the power to ban such parties.
Organization
The court has two senates. Each senate has eight members and a chairperson. Each senate's members are split into three smaller groups called chambers, and each chamber has three judges. Most decisions need a majority vote. Big decisions, such as removing the President or a judge, limiting basic rights, or banning political parties, need a two-thirds vote. The court shares selected decisions on its website, and a public relations department shares some of them through press releases.
The two senates were first set up to handle different kinds of cases. The first senate was meant to hear disputes about basic rights. The second senate was meant to hear disputes between federal and state governments. The first senate had far more cases, so in 1956 the law was changed to move some work to the second senate. Later, the court was allowed to change the senates' responsibilities itself, and these changes are published in the Federal Law Gazette. Unlike most German courts, this court often shares how many judges voted for each decision. It also allows judges to write a dissenting opinion, which means explaining why they disagreed. The presidency alternates between the two senates. The current, 10th president is Stephan Harbarth.
Democratic function
The Constitutional Court makes sure that the law is followed and that political and government decisions respect the rights of each person in the Basic Law. It can check whether laws proposed by the federal or state governments are democratic and constitutional. It can also review decisions made by the government, such as those about taxes. It also settles disagreements between the states and the federal government about how laws are carried out. It can ban political parties that are not democratic. This is its most debated power.
The Constitutional Court is trusted by the public more than the federal or state parliaments. This may come from the German love of the rule of law.
Appointment of judges
See also: List of justices of the Federal Constitutional Court
The Bundestag (the German parliament) and the Bundesrat (a group that represents the sixteen state governments) choose the court's judges. Each of them picks four judges for each senate, and each choice needs a two-thirds vote. Until 2015, the Bundestag left this job to a small group called the Richterwahlausschuss (judges' election committee). Many experts thought this method was not allowed by the constitution. In 2015, the law changed so that the Bundestag itself votes for judges in secret. Judges serve a 12-year term and must retire at age 68. They cannot be chosen again. They must be at least 40 years old and be trained lawyers. After their term ends, most judges leave public life. One well-known exception is Roman Herzog, who became President of Germany in 1994, shortly before his term as president of the court ended.
The court's leader is its president, who leads one senate. The vice president leads the other senate. The Bundestag and the Bundesrat take turns choosing the president. Since 1983, the vice president has always become the president. The president ranks fifth in the German order of precedence, which is the list of who comes first at official events. The president is the highest-ranking member of the judicial branch of government. In 2024, the constitution was changed to include the judges' term and age limit. Changing them now needs a two-thirds majority in both the Bundestag and the Bundesrat.
| Name | Term | Nomination by | Election by |
|---|---|---|---|
| First Senate | |||
| Stephan Harbarth (born 1971) (President of the Court, Chairman of the First Senate) | November 2018 – November 2030 (12-year-term) | CDU/CSU | Bundestag (as judge) Bundesrat (as president) |
| Miriam Meßling (born 1973) | April 2023 – April 2035 (12-year term) | SPD | Bundesrat |
| Yvonne Ott (born 1963) | November 2016 – November 2028 (12-year-term) | SPD | Bundesrat |
| Henning Radtke (born 1962) | July 2018 – May 2030 (retirement) | CDU/CSU | Bundesrat |
| Ines Härtel (born 1972) | July 2020 – July 2032 (12-year term) | SPD | Bundesrat |
| Heinrich Amadeus Wolff (born 1965) | June 2022 – June 2033 (retirement) | FDP | Bundestag |
| Martin Eifert (born 1965) | February 2023 – 2033 (retirement) | Greens | Bundestag |
| Günter Spinner (born 1972) | November 2025 – November 2037 (12-year-term) | CDU/CSU | Bundestag |
| Second Senate | |||
| Ann-Katrin Kaufhold (born 1976) (Vice president of the Court, Chairwoman of the Second Senate) | November 2025 – November 2037 (12-year-term) | SPD | Bundestag (as judge) Bundesrat (as vice president) |
| Christine Langenfeld (born 1962) | July 2016 – July 2028 (12-year term) | CDU/CSU | Bundesrat |
| Astrid Wallrabenstein (born 1969) | June 2020 – June 2032 (12-year term) | Greens | Bundesrat |
| Rhona Fetzer (born 1963) | January 2023 – September 2031 (retirement) | SPD | Bundestag |
| Thomas Offenloch (born 1972) | January 2023 – January 2035 (12-year term) | FDP | Bundestag |
| Peter Frank (born 1968) | December 2023 – December 2035 (12-year term) | CDU/CSU | Bundesrat |
| Holger Wöckel (born 1976) | December 2023 – December 2035 (12-year term) | CDU/CSU | Bundesrat |
| Sigrid Emmenegger (born 1976) | November 2025 – November 2037 (12-year-term) | SPD | Bundestag |
| No. | Portrait | Name (birth-death) | Previous service before court appointment | Took office | Left office | Sen. | Vice president |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hermann Höpker-Aschoff (1883–1954) | Member of the Bundestag (1949–1951) | 7 September 1951 | 15 January 1954 (died in office) | 1st | Rudolf Katz (1951–1954) | |
| 2 | Josef Wintrich (1891–1958) | President of the Munich Regional court of appeal (1953) | 23 March 1954 | 19 October 1958 (died in office) | 1st | Rudolf Katz (1954–1958) | |
| 3 | Gebhard Müller (1900–1990) | Minister President of Baden-Württemberg (1953–1958) | 8 January 1959 | 8 December 1971 | 1st | Rudolf Katz (1959–1961), Friedrich Wilhelm Wagner (1961–1967), Walter Seuffert (1967–1971) | |
| 4 | Ernst Benda (1925–2009) | Member of the Bundestag (1957–1971) | 8 December 1971 | 20 December 1983 | 1st | Walter Seuffert (1971–1975), Wolfgang Zeidler (1975–1983) | |
| 5 | Wolfgang Zeidler (1924–1987) | President of the Federal Administrative Court (1970–1975) | 20 December 1983 | 16 November 1987 | 2nd | Roman Herzog (1983–1987) | |
| 6 | Roman Herzog (1934–2017) | Baden-Württemberg State Minister of the Interior (1980–1983) | 16 November 1987 | 30 June 1994 (resigned) | 1st | Ernst Gottfried Mahrenholz (1987–1994), Jutta Limbach (1994) | |
| 7 | Jutta Limbach (1934–2016) | Berlin Senator of Justice (1989–1994) | 14 September 1994 | 10 April 2002 | 2nd | Johann Friedrich Henschel (1994–1995), Otto Seidl (1995–1998), Hans-Jürgen Papier (1998–2002) | |
| 8 | Hans-Jürgen Papier (b. 1943) | Professor for constitutional law at LMU Munich (1992–1998) | 10 April 2002 | 16 March 2010 | 1st | Winfried Hassemer (2002–2008), Andreas Voßkuhle (2008–2010) | |
| 9 | Andreas Voßkuhle (b. 1963) | Professor for political science and legal philosophy at the University of Freiburg (since 1999) Rector of the University of Freiburg (2008) | 16 March 2010 | 22 June 2020 | 2nd | Ferdinand Kirchhof (2010–2018), Stephan Harbarth (2018–2020) | |
| 10 | Stephan Harbarth (b. 1971) | Member of the Bundestag (2009–2018) | 22 June 2020 | 1st | Doris König (since 2020) |
Criticism
Some people have criticized the court. One complaint is that it acts like a replacement lawmaker (German: Ersatzgesetzgeber). The court has often struck down controversial laws, such as the Luftsicherheitsgesetz, Berlin's rent cap (Mietendeckel), and parts of the Ostpolitik. Some people feel this gets in the way of the normal work of parliament.
Another criticism came from August Hanning, a former president of the Federal Intelligence Service. He said the court tends to protect people too much, even members of ISIS. He believed this makes German intelligence agencies less effective, because the court puts more focus on protecting people in faraway countries. Finally, many of the court's decisions have been criticized, and some have led to demonstrations.
Landmark decisions
| Year | Case | Unofficial name | Synopsis | Legal principles set | Consequences |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Human dignity | |||||
| 1993 | 2 BvF 2/90 | (None) | Federal lawmakers permitted abortion within twelve weeks after implantation. To be legal the expectant mother had to go to a pregnancy consultation minimum three days in advance and the abortion has to be their own decision. | If a pregnancy is not the result of a criminal interaction or a threat to the mother's life or health an abortion violates the right to life of an embryo. As a result, in the last case, abortion has to be prohibited. | Following the decision the lawmakers changed the criminal law. They prohibited abortion within twelve weeks but after using a pregnancy consultation all participants go unpunished. |
| 2003 | 1 BvR 426/02 | Benetton II | The Federal Court of Justice prohibited the magazine Stern to publish a shocking advertisement of the Benetton Group. The advertisement showed a bare bottom with a stamp: "HIV-positive". | Human dignity is absolute. All fundamental rights are substantiations of human dignity therefore there is no trade-off of human dignity and any fundamental right possible. | The case was remanded to the Federal Court of Justice for a second time. After Benetton II the plaintiff abandoned the lawsuit. A final decision was unnecessary. |
| 2006 | 1 BvR 357/05 | Civil aviation security act decision | Federal lawmakers permitted the military to shoot down civil aeroplanes if there is an indication that they will be used as a weapon against human lives and a shoot-down is the last resort. | Human dignity is inviolable. There cannot be any trade-off of the lives of innocent people. The military can be used as disaster relief, but the use of military weapons violates the constitution. Only the federal government can order the military to provide disaster relief. | The disputed part of the civil aviation security act was declared void. Basically, the court decided that a shoot-down could be legal if a flight vehicle is unmanned or there are only suspects on board. |
| Protection of fundamental rights | |||||
| 1957 | 1 BvR 253/56 | Elfes-Decision (Elfes-Urteil) | Wilhelm Elfes, a left-wing member of the centre-right CDU, was accused of working against the constitution but was never convicted. Based on this indictment he was denied a passport multiple times. Elfes litigated against the decision. | The right to personal liberty is to be construed in a broad way. Invention of "Heck's Formula" (named after the rapporteur of the case, Justice Heck). The court can only review cases if one of the following conditions applies: The impact of a constitutional norm was misjudged Application of the law was discretionary Judicial restraint was violated | Elfes lost his specific case but the court cemented personal liberty in general. Justice Heck defined the limits of the court relative to the specialised court system. |
| 1958 | 1 BvR 400/51 | Lüth Decision (Lüth-Urteil) | The court of Hamburg prohibited Erich Lüth to call for a boycott of the film Immortal Beloved. Lüth justified his action because director Veit Harlan also was responsible for the antisemitic movie Jud Süß in 1940. | The Basic Law binds private law indirectly. The Federal Constitutional Court is not a regular appellate court on violation of federal law. The court only overviews violation of the Basic Law. | With the Lüth Decision the court defined and restricted its own power. But on the other hand, it expanded the effective range of the Basic Law beyond the tension of government and people to the private law. The Basic Law does not bind citizens but it binds the lawmakers in creating private law and the judiciary in interpreting it. |
| 2021 | 1 BvR 2656/18 1 BvR 78/20 1 BvR 96/20 1 BvR 288/20 | (Klimaschutz) | In 2019 the German federal government implemented the Climate Protection Act, to transpose the Paris Agreement into German law. It defined CO2-reduction goals for 2030 but did not describe how to reach the 1.5 °C/2 °C limitation beyond that year. The German branch of Fridays for Future litigated against the law because it would put an undue burden to their freedom and the freedom of the generations to come. | The Basic Law binds legislation to protect the liberty of actual people as well as the freedoms of generations to come. Legislation has to implement laws in a way that does not put an undue burden on the liberty of young people or future generations. The decision was unanimous. | The court instructed the federal government to implement the law in a way that does not put most of the effort needed to reach the goals of the Paris Agreement to future generations. Personal liberty is not to be interpreted in a way that restricts the personal liberty of future generations inappropriately. |
| Development of fundamental rights by the court | |||||
| 1983 | 1 BvR 209/83 1 BvR 269/83 1 BvR 362/83 1 BvR 420/83 1 BvR 440/83 1 BvR 484/83 | Census Verdict (Volkszählungsurteil) | Citizens litigated against the German census 1983 | Personal freedom under modern conditions depends on the right to be protected against unlimited data processing, use, collection, storage and disclosure. There is nothing like irrelevant data. | The census was postponed to 1987 until the "census 1983 act" was changed corresponding to the verdict. The court created, by deriving from human dignity and personal liberty, a new civil right: informational self-determination. The verdict became the foundation of the modern German Data Protection Act (1990) and the EU Data Protection Directive (1998). |
| 2018 | 1 BvR 3080/09 | Stadium ban decision (Stadionverbots-Entscheidung) | Soccer Fan litigating against nationwide stadium ban | Mittelbare Drittwirkung applies to some powerful non-state organisations within some specific constellations, mandating the protection of individual right. | Higher requirements for the exclusion of individuals from some public events, indirect impact on the actions of large platforms. |
| Freedom of expression | |||||
| 2000 | 1 BvR 1762/95 & 1 BvR 1787/95 | Benetton I | The Federal Court of Justice prohibited the magazine Stern to publish shocking advertisements of the Benetton Group. The advertisements showed a bird doused with oil, child labour and a bare buttock with a stamp: "HIV-positive". | The publishing of an opinion of a third party that is protected by freedom of expression is protected itself. | The case was remanded to the Federal Court of Justice whose new decision was challenged again as "Benetton II". |
| Freedom of art | |||||
| 1971 | 1 BvR 435/68 | Mephisto judgment (Mephisto-Entscheidung) | The heir of Gustaf Gründgens successfully sued the publisher of the 1936 novel Mephisto by Gründgens' former brother-in-law Klaus Mann to stop publishing the book. It was prohibited by all lower courts. | Freedom of art is guaranteed by the Basic Law, but it finds its limit in human dignity and likewise in personality right. Because freedom of art is to be construed in a broad sense, weighing up has to be comprehensive and a case by case decision. | Due to a split decision the ban of the novel was upheld. It was the first decision of the court on the interpretation of freedom of art. Apart from the concrete decision, the court made clear that freedom of art cannot be limited by general laws. |
Impact on European constitutional questions
On 12 September 2012, the Court said it would examine whether the ECB's decision to help European countries by buying bonds on the secondary markets was ultra vires. This meant checking whether the decision went beyond the limits set by the German law that approved the ESM. The case showed how a group of citizens can affect the actions of European institutions. On 7 February 2014, the Court made an early announcement about the case. The full ruling was to be published on 18 March. In its ruling, the Court decided to leave the judgment to the CJEU.
In a ruling on 5 May 2020, the Court found that an EU act and the Weiss Judgment of the Court of Justice had gone beyond the powers given to them by the Member States. The EU decided to start infringement proceedings against Germany. In response, the German government gave the European Commission assurances that satisfied it. As a result, the case was closed in December 2021.

Quiz time!
4 questions about Federal Constitutional Court
What document set up the Federal Constitutional Court?
Pictures
Keep exploring
This article is a child-friendly adaptation of the Wikipedia article on Federal Constitutional Court, available under CC BY-SA 4.0.
Images from Wikimedia Commons. Tap any image to view credits and license.