Safekipedia

Parmenides (dialogue)

Adventurer · ages 7–10Adapted from Wikipedia
Plato, one of the great thinkers of ancient Greece, as he appears in Raphael's famous painting 'The School of Athens.'

Parmenides (Greek: Παρμενίδης) is one of the dialogues of Plato. Many people think it is the hardest and most mysterious of Plato's dialogues.

The dialogue pretends to show a meeting between two great philosophers of the Eleatic school, Parmenides and Zeno of Elea, and a young Socrates. The meeting happens when Zeno reads his written work. His work defends the ideas of Parmenides. Zeno argues against people who believe in many things instead of one. He defends monism, the idea that there is a "one." He says that these people's ideas about many things lead to silly and contradictory results.

Parmenides

The conversation takes place in Athens, Socrates' home city. It is the earliest of Plato's dialogues in time, because Socrates is only nineteen years old. So Socrates takes the role of the student, and Parmenides acts as the teacher.

Most scholars agree that the conversation did not really happen. They think Plato most likely made it up.

Discussion with Socrates

The dialogue begins with Socrates questioning the old and respected Parmenides and Zeno. Zeno uses his usual method, the reductio ad absurdum, to argue that if things are many, they would be both like and unlike, which cannot be true. Socrates says this problem goes away if we separate sensibles from Forms, which the sensibles take part in. One thing can then be both like and unlike, or both Unity and Plurality, by taking part in different Forms. Then Parmenides takes over the conversation and asks Socrates which Forms he accepts. Socrates is sure about mathematical, moral, and beautiful Forms, such as Goodness and Beauty. He is unsure about Forms of Man, Fire, and Water. He almost certainly doubts that hair, mud, and dirt have Forms.

Parmenides then gives five arguments against the theory of Forms. One of the best known is the Third Man Argument, which shows a never-ending chain of Forms. Socrates cannot defend the theory against these arguments, but Parmenides himself seems to support it. He says that without Forms, there could be no real discussion, and that Socrates has not practiced enough. The rest of the dialogue is a practice session. A young Aristoteles, who later became one of the Thirty Tyrants and should not be confused with Aristotle, takes Socrates' place in talking with Parmenides.

Discussion with Aristoteles

The second part of this dialogue is often seen as one of the hardest and strangest parts of Plato's writings. It is a long series of difficult arguments, with little of the drama and colour found in his earlier dialogues. These arguments ask what follows from "if the one is" and from "if the one is not." If the one is, it has no parts and no shape, and it does not move. Yet it is also part of being, and it seems to be both still and moving. If the one is not, then everything is partly one, so being itself is not.

Many thinkers have tried to explain this part, including Cornford, Russell, Ryle, and Owen. However, few would say any of them has fully explained it. Scholars still disagree about even basic points. Benjamin Jowett argued that the dialogue was not a clear disproof of the Eleatic teaching. He suggested it might instead be an Eleatic judgement of the theory of Forms. The discussion deals with ideas that Plato cared about in his later dialogues, such as Being, Sameness, Difference, and Unity.

Third Man argument

Plato's theory of Forms appears in the Phaedo, the Republic, and the first part of the Parmenides. It seems to rest on several main ideas. The word "Form" comes from the Ancient Greek word εἶδος (eîdos, romanized: eîdos), which first meant "appearance, shape."

The Third Man argument shows that these ideas do not fit together when there is more than one great thing. Take three great things, A, B, and C. They are great because of a Form of greatness, G1. But G1 is also great, so it can join the group. Then it needs another Form of greatness, G2. The same reasoning keeps going, creating an endless chain of Forms of greatness. This goes against the idea that each property has exactly one Form, and that a Form is one, not many.

Legacy

Aristotle described the Third Man argument in works such as Metaphysics and Sophistic Refutations. He said the idea came from Plato. Aristotle did not use Plato's example of "greatness." He used "man" instead, which is how the argument got its name. He explained that if a man is a man because he shares in the Form of Man, then a third Form would be needed to explain how both the man and the Form of Man are men. And then another would be needed, and so on ad infinitum.

Many Neoplatonic writers studied the Parmenides and wrote commentaries to explain it. Some of the most important came from Proclus, Damascius, and an unknown writer who may have been Porphyry. In the 1200s, William of Moerbeke translated Proclus' commentary, and this made people interested in the dialogue again. In the 1400s, Nicolas of Cusa was influenced by Proclus. Giovanni Pico della Mirandola and Marsilio Ficino also wrote major commentaries. Ficino believed Plato put all of theology into the Parmenides. Today, some scholars, including Gregory Vlastos, see the Third Man argument as a sign of honest puzzlement. Others think Plato wanted readers to reject one of the ideas that leads to the endless chain.

Translations

Many scholars have translated the Parmenides dialogue. Some books show the original Greek next to English or German. Many also include notes to help readers understand it.

  • Burnet, J. Platonis Opera, Vol. II. Oxford University Press, 1903. ISBN 978-0-19-814541-7 (Greek with critical apparatus)
  • Fowler, H. N. Plato, Vol. IV. Harvard University Press, 1926. Loeb Classical Library 167. ISBN 978-0-674-99185-9 (Greek and English)
  • Zekl, H. G. Parmenides. Meiner Verlag, 1972. ISBN 978-3-7873-0280-2 (Greek and German)
  • Allen, R. E. The Dialogues of Plato, Volume IV: Plato's Parmenides, Revised Edition. Yale University Press, 1997. ISBN 978-0-300-07729-2 (English with commentary)
  • Cornford, F. M.. Plato and Parmenides. Routledge, 1939. ISBN 978-0-415-22517-5 (English with commentary)
  • Gill, M. L., and P. Ryan. Plato: Parmenides. Hackett Publishing, 1996. ISBN 978-0-87220-329-7 (English with notes)
  • Scolnicov, S. Plato's Parmenides. University of California Press, 2003. ISBN 978-0-520-22403-2 (English with commentary)
  • Turnbull, R. The Parmenides and Plato's Late Philosophy. University of Toronto Press, 1998. ISBN 978-0-8020-4236-1 (English with commentary)
  • Hermann, A., and S. Chrysakopoulou. Plato's Parmenides: Text, Translation, and Introductory Essay. Parmenides Publishing, 2010. ISBN 978-1-930972-20-9 (Greek and English, with English commentary)

Quiz time!

4 questions about Parmenides (dialogue)

Question 1 of 4

Which two great philosophers meet a young Socrates in this dialogue?

Pictures

A marble bust of the ancient Greek philosopher Socrates. This Roman copy was made from a Greek original from the 4th century BC and is displayed in the Vatican Museums.
A classical marble-style bust of Socrates, the ancient Greek philosopher known for his questions about wisdom, justice, and how we should live.

Keep exploring

This article is a child-friendly adaptation of the Wikipedia article on Parmenides (dialogue), available under CC BY-SA 4.0.

Images from Wikimedia Commons. Tap any image to view credits and license.