Safekipedia

Meno

Adventurer · ages 7–10Adapted from Wikipedia
A marble bust of the ancient Greek philosopher Socrates. This Roman copy was made after a original Greek sculpture from the 4th century BC and is displayed in the Vatican Museums.

Meno is a Socratic dialogue written by Plato around 385 BC. It is set at an earlier time, around 402 BC. This article is about Plato's dialogue. For the Thessalian general and character from Plato's dialogue, see Meno (general). For other uses, see Meno (disambiguation).

The dialogue begins when Meno asks Socrates whether virtue (in Ancient Greek: ἀρετή, aretē) can be taught, gained through practice, or comes from nature. Socrates says they first need to decide what virtue is. They talk about virtue in general, not about specific virtues like justice or temperance. The first part of the work shows the Socratic dialectical style. Meno cannot define virtue well and becomes confused, which is called aporia. Socrates suggests that they look for a good definition together. Meno replies that it is impossible to search for something you do not know, because you would not be able to tell if you had found it.

Socrates answers this argument, which is often called "Meno's Paradox", "Learner's Paradox", or the "Arabic Paradox". He explains the idea of knowledge as recollection (anamnesis). In the dialogue, this idea says that souls live forever and know everything before they enter a body. So learning is a process of remembering what the soul already knew. To show this, Socrates gives a math puzzle to one of Meno's slaves. Later, Socrates and Meno return to whether virtue can be taught, using a method called hypothesis.

Near the end of the dialogue, Meno raises another well-known puzzle, called "the Meno problem" or "the Value Problem for Knowledge". It asks why knowledge is valued more highly than true belief. Socrates responds with a famous and somewhat mysterious difference between knowledge and true belief.

Characters

Plato's Meno is a dialogue, or conversation, between Socrates and Meno (also transliterated as "Menon"). They talk about virtue, which means being good, and whether it can be taught. Meno is visiting Athens from Thessaly. He travels with a large group of slaves who attend him. He is young, handsome, and comes from a wealthy family. He studies with Gorgias, a well-known sophist, and Gorgias's ideas seem to shape Meno's own. Early in the dialogue, Meno says that he has often spoken about virtue, sometimes in front of large crowds.

One of Meno's slaves also has a speaking part. Socrates talks with the slave to explain his idea of anamnesis. This is the idea that some knowledge is already inside us, and the soul can "recollect" it by asking good questions. Later in the dialogue, the Athenian politician Anytus joins the discussion. He is friendly with Meno. Later, he becomes one of the prosecutors of Socrates.

Dialogue

Meno asks Socrates whether virtue can be taught, gained through practice, or comes by nature. Socrates says he does not know what virtue is. Meno says that his teacher, Gorgias, believes virtue is different for different people. For a man, it means helping friends and harming enemies. For a woman, it means running the household and obeying her husband. Children and old men, whether free or slaves, also have their own virtues. Socrates argues that there must be one virtue shared by all people, such as sophrosunê ('temperance', or self-control) and dikê ('justice'). He points out that Meno lists many virtues without finding what makes them all virtues. No good definition is found. Socrates says a good definition must be a single idea, not a list, and must not be circular.

Depiction of an Athenian slave from 380 to 370 BC, National Archaeological Museum of Athens

Meno then asks how anyone can search for something they do not know. This puzzle is called Meno's paradox. Socrates answers with a mythos ('story') that souls are immortal and learn everything before transmigrating into the body. So learning is recollection, which needs Socratic questioning. This idea is central to the argument for inborn knowledge. Socrates draws a square in the ground and questions a slave who knows no geometry. The slave guesses wrong twice before reasoning his way to the answer, which Socrates says he had known before birth. Socrates then clashes with Anytus, son of Anthemion, when he questions whether famous men such as Themistocles, Aristides, Pericles and Thucydides passed virtue on to their sons. Anytus accuses Socrates of slander. Anytus was also one of Socrates's accusers at his trial. Socrates later separates "true belief" from "knowledge." This idea leads to the definition of knowledge as justified true belief. However, Myles Burnyeat argues that the phrase aitias logismos means working out a solution rather than giving a justification. Socrates ends by suggesting that virtue comes from divine inspiration, but knowing what virtue is still needs the question "what is virtue?" The idea that knowledge is more valuable than true belief is known as the Meno problem. The nature of knowledge is also discussed in the Theaetetus. The anamnesis (recollection) idea appears throughout.

Meno and Protagoras

The theme of Meno is also explored in another dialogue, Protagoras. In that dialogue, Plato has Socrates reach the opposite conclusion: virtue can be taught.

The two dialogues also differ in how they view knowledge. In Protagoras, knowledge is tied to this world. In Meno, the idea of recollection suggests that knowledge is linked to eternal truths.

Texts and translations

This section lists some places where you can read Meno in English. Some versions were translated by different people. Sources include Standard Ebooks, Project Gutenberg, Harvard University Press, the Perseus Project, and SSRN. Jowett, Benjamin and others also translated the dialogue.

Quiz time!

4 questions about Meno

Question 1 of 4

What question does Meno ask Socrates at the start of the dialogue?

Pictures

Plato, the ancient Greek philosopher, as he appears in Raphael's painting 'The School of Athens,' a famous Renaissance artwork.
A bust of Socrates, the ancient Greek philosopher known for asking big questions about truth, justice, and how we should live.
An animated diagram showing how to double the area of a square, as explored by Socrates in Plato's dialogue Meno.

Keep exploring

This article is a child-friendly adaptation of the Wikipedia article on Meno, available under CC BY-SA 4.0.

Images from Wikimedia Commons. Tap any image to view credits and license.