Safekipedia

Socratic method

Adventurer · ages 7–10Adapted from Wikipedia
Alcibiades Being Taught by Socrates, a painting by Marcello Bacciarelli from 1776–77, showing the philosopher Socrates teaching a young student.

For the TV episode, see The Socratic Method (House).

Marcello Bacciarelli's Alcibiades Being Taught by Socrates (1776)

The Socratic method is a way of talking that involves arguing. One person asks another person questions about a topic and asks them to explain their ideas more clearly. The partner is guided to reach a conclusion on their own. Or their reasoning falls apart, and they have to admit they do not know. The method is also called Socratic debate, the maieutic method, or the Socratic dialectic. It is sometimes said to be the same as the Greek word elenchus. Socratic dialogues are conversations that appear in many works by the ancient Greek philosopher Plato. In these works, a made-up version of his real teacher, Socrates, talks through big ideas with a partner.

In Plato's dialogue Theaetetus, Socrates describes his method as a kind of "midwifery" (maieutikós, which gives the English word maieutic). He compares it to helping people bring out their understanding. This is like a child developing in the womb that grows until it is ready to be born. The method starts with beliefs that people commonly hold. Then it checks them with questions, to see whether they make sense and fit with other beliefs. This helps everyone come closer to the truth.

Today, changed forms of the Socratic method are used in many teaching settings.

In the second half of the 5th century BC, sophists were teachers. They used the tools of philosophy and rhetoric to entertain, impress, or persuade people to agree with their point of view. Socrates promoted a different way of teaching, which came to be called the Socratic method. He started these discussions with his fellow Athenians after his old friend Chaerephon visited the Oracle of Delphi. The oracle said that no man in Greece was wiser than Socrates. Socrates found this puzzling, a paradox, and used the Socratic method to try to understand it. Diogenes Laërtius, however, wrote that Protagoras invented the "Socratic" method.

Plato wrote down the Socratic elenctic style in some of his early dialogues, such as Euthyphro and Ion. In these, Socrates questions a well-known Athenian. The method is most often found in the so-called "Socratic dialogues," in which Socrates asks his fellow citizens questions about right and wrong and about how we know things. In his later dialogues, such as Theaetetus or Sophist, Plato used a different approach to philosophical discussion, called dialecticepistemological.

Method

The main technique of the Socratic method is called elenchus-style testing. It means examining an idea closely, especially to show where it is wrong. Socrates, as shown in Plato's writings, used this method to examine ideas such as the virtues of piety, wisdom, temperance, courage, and justice. His questions tested the hidden moral beliefs of the people he spoke with. They showed where those beliefs did not fit together, often leading to aporia, a state of puzzlement. Socrates said he knew he was ignorant, and that this made him wiser than people who claimed to know things they did not. He rarely built complete theories and often used allegories. In the Parmenides dialogue, Parmenides uses the method to point out flaws in the theory of forms.

Scholars still discuss how the method works. Gregory Vlastos described steps in which an interlocutor states an idea. Socrates then gets agreement to other ideas that contradict it, and then Socrates claims the first idea is false. Michael Frede pointed out that showing an idea is false does not prove another idea is true. Instead, the people in the conversation reach a state of aporetic uncertainty. Some scholars ask whether the method leads to knowledge or only shows that false claims are wrong. W. K. C. Guthrie argued that the method aims to show a person's ignorance. Unlike the Sophists, Socrates believed knowledge was possible. He thought the first step was recognizing one's own ignorance.

Modern applications

A Socratic seminar, also called a Socratic circle, is a way of learning that uses a dialogic approach to understand a text. Students ask and answer questions to explore what they have read. It is not a debate, and nobody tries to "win." Instead, the group works together to build meaning. Often, an inner circle talks about the text while an outer circle listens quietly. Then the outer circle shares its observations and gives helpful criticism, not judgements. The circles take turns. The students lead the discussion, while the facilitator helps the talk keep moving. Some teachers use triads, where each speaker in the inner circle has two co-pilots who talk with them during pauses. Others use simultaneous seminars, where small groups discuss different texts around one main topic.

A good seminar text has complex ideas that can be read in many ways. This is called Ambiguity. Because there is no single right answer, everyone can share their views. Questions are open-ended and focus on big, general ideas rather than facts, using Socratic questioning. The pedagogy of this approach helps students gain experience and become better at starting discussions. Scholars such as Peter Boghossian say the method can build creative and critical thinking. They also warn that it can make people feel bad if it is used poorly. Boghossian argues that teachers must make sure students are not laughed at or made to feel small.

Psychotherapy

The Socratic method, in the form of Socratic questioning, has been adapted for psychotherapy. It is most common in classical Adlerian psychotherapy, logotherapy, rational emotive behavior therapy, cognitive therapy and reality therapy. Therapists use it to help people understand what their words and feelings mean, to slowly gain insight, or to think about other ways to act.

The Socratic method has also inspired a newer way of doing philosophy called Socratic dialogue, which is also known as philosophical counseling. In Europe, Gerd B. Achenbach is probably the best known person who does this work. Michel Weber has also suggested another version of the practice.

Quiz time!

4 questions about Socratic method

Question 1 of 4

What is the Socratic method?

Pictures

A carved stone bust of the ancient Greek philosopher Socrates, displayed at the University of Western Australia in Crawley, Western Australia.
A painting by Cesare Maccari showing the Roman senator Cicero speaking out against Catiline's plot to overthrow the Roman Republic.
A marble bust of the ancient Greek philosopher Socrates. It is a Roman copy made after a Greek original from the 4th century BC, and it was found at the Quintili Villa on the Via Appia near Rome.
A classical bust of Socrates, the ancient Greek philosopher who taught through questions and conversation.

Keep exploring

This article is a child-friendly adaptation of the Wikipedia article on Socratic method, available under CC BY-SA 4.0.

Images from Wikimedia Commons. Tap any image to view credits and license.