Safekipedia

Sophist (dialogue)

Adventurer · ages 7–10Adapted from Wikipedia
Plato, the ancient Greek philosopher, as he appears in Raphael's painting 'The School of Athens.'

The Sophist (Greek: Σοφιστής; Latin: Sophista) is a Platonic dialogue written by the philosopher Plato near the end of his life. It was most likely written in 360 BC.

In this dialogue, the speakers are guided by an Eleatic Stranger. They use the method of division to sort and describe the sophist. They also explain his main traits and how he is different from the philosopher and the statesman.

Like its sequel, the Statesman, this dialogue is unusual because Socrates is there but has only a small part. Instead, the Eleatic Stranger leads the discussion.

Because Socrates stays quiet, it is hard to know whether the views of the Eleatic Stranger really belong to Plato. It is hard to say that any character in a story speaks for the author.

Background

The main goal of the dialogue is to find out what a sophist is. It also asks how a sophist is different from a philosopher and a statesman. Each of these seems to be known for a special kind of knowledge. The dialogue continues some ideas from the epistemological dialogue Theaetetus, which is said to have taken place the day before. Because the Sophist deals with these ideas, it is often seen as a way to understand Plato's Theory of Forms. It is also compared with the Parmenides, which questioned what is often thought to be the theory of forms.

The Cratylus was written around the same time as the Republic, or a little before it. In this work, Plato asks how names relate to things, and how words relate to reality. This question is important for using dialectics to gain knowledge, so the Sophist has the Cratylus as its main background. The Cratylus compares two views. Hermogenes thinks a name is a set of sounds that people agree on to refer to an object. Cratylus, a student of the older Heraclitus, believed a name should fully show the essence of what it names. After this, the Sophist focuses on finding the right definition of the word "sophist." Some scholars have argued that Plato sometimes agreed with Hermogenes and sometimes with Cratylus. In 1976, Gérard Genette argued that the link between language and objects is not natural but shaped by culture. The linguist Ferdinand de Saussure also supported this idea. It has been important in the development of Linguistics. In 2007, Gaetano Licata argued that Plato accepted Cratylus' view. The idea of language and "true discourse" from the Cratylus will be very important for studying diairetic dialectic in the Sophist.

Introduction

This dialogue takes place a day after Plato's Theaetetus in a gymnasium in Athens. The people talking are Socrates, who has a small part, the older mathematician Theodorus, the young mathematician Theaetetus, and a visitor from Elea, the hometown of Parmenides and Zeno. This visitor is often called the Eleatic Stranger or the Eleatic Visitor. Other young mathematicians are also there, but they stay quiet.

The dialogue begins when Socrates arrives and asks the Eleatic Stranger whether, in his homeland, a sophist, a statesperson, and a philosopher are seen as one kind of person or three. The Eleatic Stranger says they are three. Then he starts to explain what a sophist is by talking with Theaetetus.

Method of definition (216a–236d)

Further information: Diairesis

The Eleatic Stranger tries a different way of defining things than Plato uses in his other dialogues. He compares the sophist to a model and a fisherman, because all three have a certain skill (techne) in one subject. He sorts many activities into groups, then divides those groups into smaller kinds, and he does this again and again. This way, he places the sophist among the merchants. He also compares the model and the sophist to see what they share and how they differ. Along the way, he notices qualities, similar to the Categories of Aristotle, that can be used to compare kinds. In the end, he describes sophistry as a kind of imitation that copies the wise man.

The sophist is described in a negative way, as someone who only pretends to know things. This would only be true if right opinion and false opinion can be told apart. The Stranger says the problem comes from Parmenides' ideas about being and non-being, so he criticizes those ideas.

Puzzles of being and not-being, great kinds (236d–264b)

The Eleatic Stranger first explains the big ideas he used to define sophistry. These ideas are Being, Not-Being, sameness, difference, motion (change), and rest. He shows how they connect. He compares the ideas of Parmenides with those of Empedocles and Heraclitus to ask whether Being is the same as change, rest, or both. He decides that rest and change both "are," meaning both are beings. Parmenides had said only rest "is." Being is something that all existing things share. Sameness is what things in the same group have in common, so we can sort them into groups. Difference makes things in the same group different from one another. Not-Being is not the opposite of Being. It is simply different from it.

These ideas help explain how a true statement can be told apart from a false one. Every statement has a name, which points to the subject, and a verb, which shows what the subject does or what happens to it. A statement is true when the verb describes a real quality of the subject. It is false when the verb describes something different. A false statement does not give being to something that is not. This suggests that the sophist makes false appearances and copies the wise person.

Final definition (264b–268d)

After solving these puzzles, the Eleatic Stranger can finally define sophistry. The puzzles are about how being, not-being, difference, and negation relate to each other. They also ask whether something can appear to be real when it is not.

The definition is that sophistry is a human skill that makes things. It is a skill of imitation that makes copies and appearances. It is not based on real knowledge, and it is not honest. It takes the form of a skill that produces speech which argues against other speech.

Quiz time!

4 questions about Sophist (dialogue)

Question 1 of 4

Who wrote the dialogue called The Sophist?

Pictures

A marble bust of the ancient Greek philosopher Socrates, carved by Romans who copied an earlier Greek original from the 4th century BC. It is displayed in the Vatican Museums.
A bust of Socrates, the ancient Greek philosopher who taught by asking questions.

Keep exploring

This article is a child-friendly adaptation of the Wikipedia article on Sophist (dialogue), available under CC BY-SA 4.0.

Images from Wikimedia Commons. Tap any image to view credits and license.